Our representatives are available to schedule your appointment Monday through Friday from 9am to 5pm.
For a Northwell ambulance, call
(833) 259-2367.
Early on in the COVID-19 pandemic, physicians observed that men were more likely to die or to require treatment in an intensive care unit than women. This observation was later confirmed in a study of 10,600 adult patients in our health system, reminding us yet again that, for most diseases, biologic sex — which is to say, the sex you were assigned at birth — influences the susceptibility, symptoms, clinical course and response to treatment.
We are physicians and scientists, but we’re not so cloistered in our gleaming labs and exam rooms as to ignore the robust discussion unfolding about sex, gender and the way the two intersect and shape our understanding of ourselves and of others. We believe these discussions are fruitful and important tools to understanding and overcoming years of misrepresentation and discrimination.
And yet, as physicians, we want to interject an important reminder that often gets lost in the noise: While gender is a changing social construct we use to describe our perceptions about the respective roles of men and women, it is also true we all have a biologic sex. As COVID just reminded us, it is extremely important when treating patients not to lose sight of this biologic sex — as we run the risk of doing, say, when we speak of “birthing people” instead of birthing women — and how it might contribute to the progression of a disease.
Heart disease is a prime example: It is the leading killer of women, but their symptoms may be very different from those seen in men and caused by different pathologic processes. As a result, women often do not receive the preventive cardiovascular care they need, and their heart attack symptoms are often ignored or minimized, leading to delayed diagnosis and treatment. Even when heart attacks are correctly diagnosed, women are less likely to receive accepted guideline-based treatments.
Despite efforts by the American Heart Association to educate the public that heart disease is the number one cause of death in women, survey data indicate that awareness has actually gone down in the 10-year period between 2009 and 2019. Recognizing the critical global problem of cardiovascular disease (CVD) in women, the Lancet, a top international medical journal, recently commissioned an all-female panel to take a fresh look at the problem and establish a research agenda to address it. This isn’t some “woke” attempt at virtue-signaling; it’s necessary and life-saving science.
Over the past several decades, women have been treated by clinicians and scientists as if they were just like men with a “one size fits all” approach to clinical care. But men and women are biologically different. We need more research to explore the genetic, anatomic, hormonal, immunologic and other factors that lead to the sex differences in all diseases, which will provide clues to how best to prevent and treat all affected individuals. This has correctly prompted the federal National Institutes of Health to require researchers to factor sex as a biological variable as a foundational part of the design, analysis and reporting of all studies it funds. This decision benefits not only women but men as well, paving the way to the much-needed practice of precision medicine in which biological sex is baked into the research, not just hammered into it as an afterthought.
The implications of this approach are likely to be considerable, and go a long way to helping us save lives, as some diseases affect one biologic sex much more commonly than the other. For example, rheumatoid arthritis, multiple sclerosis and migraines are diagnosed overwhelmingly in women, and certain liver diseases are more common in women than in men, such as autoimmune hepatitis and primary biliary cholangitis. In fact, the standards laboratories currently use when analyzing bloodwork are largely calibrated to reflect baselines corresponding to male biology, putting women at risk of misdiagnosis.
Studying biologic sex differences is not just a women’s health issue. Understanding the reasons for the differences between men and women help elucidate the mechanisms of disease, which helps everyone.
Let us, then, continue to discuss gender seriously, and let us simultaneously dedicate ourselves to the important research of how gender disparities have a very real impact on the health and well-being of our patients. But among all the other public health lessons this pandemic has taught us, let us also remember this important one: biologic sex differences are an undeniable reality, and must be properly studied and understood if we are to heal disease.
Dr. Mieres is a cardiologist and senior vice president for the Center for Equity of Care and Chief Diversity and Inclusion Officer at Northwell Health. Dr. Rosen is a cardiologist and senior vice president of Women’s Health at the Katz Institute for Women’s Health at Northwell Health. Dr. Nash is a physician and a research consultant to the Katz Institute for Women’s Health at Northwell Health.
This op-ed appeared in the New York Daily News
Our representatives are available to schedule your appointment Monday through Friday from 9am to 5pm.
For a Northwell ambulance, call
(833) 259-2367.